12-09-2009, 03:48 PM
Xbox 360 better than PS3
Informacion completa de la web:
<!-- m --><a class="postlink" href="http://www.examiner.com/x-16887-Las-Cruces-Xbox-Live-Examiner~y2009m8d30-Xbox-360-better-than-PS3-Part-one-hardware">http://www.examiner.com/x-16887-Las-Cru ... e-hardware</a><!-- m -->.
Xbox 360 better than PS3?
Part one: hardware
Since the release of the current generation of consoles, the debate has raged, not persisted, but raged about which company has the better console. However, even this question has been answered, time and time again, Sony, it's developers, and it's fans still proclaim that it is the better console. This is false.
With this generation of games there are three basic issues at hand that decide which console is the best. Hardware, Software, and online capability. We'll cover all of these in this article.
Hardware is the weapon that Sony and company touts more often than anything else. They constantly state how the PS3 is the more powerful system, because of the Cell Processor, and Blu-Ray. However, the PS3 is not the more powerful system. There is just one, Cell Proecssor, and the Blu-Ray has painful load times, while it has more space on the disk, it still loads slower than regular DLDVD format discs. This is one of the reasons a game must install to the hard drive. Sony likes to state that most of it's games wouldn't run on the Xbox 360 due to limitations of the disc. This is incorrect.
[It's] great for watching movies, but not so great for games. Getting data off the Blu-ray drive takes about twice as long as it does to get the same data off the 360's DVD drive. That translates into longer load times, or god forbid if you're streaming from disk, tighter constraints on the amount of data you can stream
For instance, in Resistance: Fall of Man, every art asset is stored on disk once for every level that uses it. So rather than storing one copy of a texture, you're storing it 12 times. If you took that entire game and removed all the duplicate data, it would likely fit on a DVD without any problem
- Jason Booth, Turbine and Harmonix Developer who produced titles such as Rock Band, and Guitar Hero.
There you have it from a developer who's made some of the most popular games today, Rock Band and Guitar Hero. So what is Blu-Ray really good for then? Watching movies? This isn't a score for Sony, because the 360 already lets you watch high definition movies in 1080p if you'd like. You can rent them from the market place, stream them from Netflix, or straight from your computer or mac. Blu-Ray may be able to hold a huge amount of data now, but is Blu-Ray really the future? No. Blu-Ray has arrived at the end of the disc era. Flash cards may very well be the next format, but digital downloads are storming consoles, especially with the 360's new ability to download full games, right onto the hard drive through Games on Demand.
Next up is graphics processing capabilities. Sony touts that it's Cell processor is more capable of providing better graphics than the Xbox's powerhouse tri-core processor. Jason booth says:
The fill rate on the PS3 is significantly slower than on the 360, meaning that games either have to run at lower resolution or use simpler shader effects to achieve the same performance, Additionally, the shader processing on the PS3 is significantly slower than on the 360, which means that a normal map takes more fill rate to draw on the PS3 than it does on the 360. And I'm not talking about small differences here, we're talking roughly half the pixel pushing power
Half of the pixel pushing power he says. Amazing. Here's a graph from an IGN and Gamespy Comparative analysis that shows the processing power of both the Xbox 360, and the PS3:
![[Image: microsofts-xbox-360-vs-sonys-playstation...728972.jpg]](http://image3.examiner.com/images/blog/wysiwyg/image/microsofts-xbox-360-vs-sonys-playstation-3-20050520041728972.jpg)
[img]For all of you interesting in reading the full article, complete with all it's technical terms read here.
Here's a graph that shows the shader operations per second, also courtesy of IGN:[/img]
![[Image: microsofts-xbox-360-vs-sonys-playstation...731425.jpg]](http://image3.examiner.com/images/blog/wysiwyg/image/microsofts-xbox-360-vs-sonys-playstation-3-20050520041731425.jpg)
The last graph we'll look at, is for system bandwidth, which is necessary for running more complex graphics.
![[Image: microsofts-xbox-360-vs-sonys-playstation...725628.jpg]](http://image3.examiner.com/images/blog/wysiwyg/image/microsofts-xbox-360-vs-sonys-playstation-3-20050520041725628.jpg)
The Cell processor is supposed to make up for this issue, however, given the history of games that have appeared on both systems, such as every game that has been made for 360 and ported to PS3, we've seen that games look significantly better on 360. Take a look at this article from The Sixth Axis, a predominately PS3 website, which showed that the PS3 couldn't support high resolution for the game Ghostbusters, without a patch, and after the patch, still called sub-hd by Gamezine.
Id Software (creators of Doom, Quake, and anticipated game Rage) director John Carmack said this:
What you can say really quite clearly and not get into too much argument about it is that the 360 is much easier to develop for, it's easier to get the performance out of it that it can deliver, and the rasterizer, the GPU side is generally faster than what the PS3 has.
And from a developer's standpoint, Gabe Newell from Valve, developer of Left 4 Dead, and Half Life 2, says,
I think [PS3 is] a waste of everybody’s time. Investing in the Cell, investing in the SPE gives you no long-term benefits. There’s nothing there that you’re going to apply to anything else. You’re not going to gain anything except a hatred of the architecture they’ve created. I don’t think they’re going to make money off their box.
So here we have multiple game developers stating what the hardware specifications reinforce. The Xbox 360 is the better system where hardware is concerned.
Part two: Software
Part two: Software
Games are always decision makers for people. Whether it's just some people, or all, they will always be a huge factor when deciding which console to buy.
Microsoft has made it it's a huge object in acquiring thirdy party software as exclusive titles to it's library. See the full list here. Please note that this list does not include games that have yet to be released.
Sony, on the other hand, has let exclusive deals go, and has even said that third party content isn't as important as first party content. The biggest thing however, is the list of former Sony exclusives who are bringing their wares to Microsoft. Here's a list of the biggest ones, some of which are new IPs that were intended to be PS3 exclusives:
* Final Fantasy XIII
* Fatal Inertia
* The Last Remnant
* Bladestorm
* Final Fantasy XIV
* Resident Evil
* Star Ocean
* Tekken
* Metal Gear Solid
* War Devil
* Merecnaries 2
* L.A. Noire
* Grand Theft Auto IV
* Assassins's Creed
* Left 4 Dead
* Splinter Cell: Conviction
Now, some of them have come across partially, while others like The Last Remnant, Star Ocean and Left 4 Dead, have come across completely as Xbox exclusives. The Xbox 360 has lost exclusivity on these games:
* Ninja Gaiden
* Lost Planet
* Bioshock
This list also doesn't include much of the Downloadable Content that Microsoft also has exclusive rights to, such as Grand Theft Auto: IV, and timed exclusive content on games like Fallout 3, and Call of Duty. Sony's exclusive games are primarily single player, whereas Xbox's are multiplayer. Single player games are becoming a thing of the past, as you can see with the Wii. Multiplayer, and cooperative play is where it's all at. The 360 has the PS3 beat here. And some people will say "oh it's because the 360 has been out longer. It's only been out for a year longer, and it has 21 more exclusives than the PS3. And they didn't all come out during that first year. Next: Online services.
Part three: Software
Part three: Software
Online is always the last weapon that Sony and it's fans use to determine which console is better. They maintain that the PS3 has better online support than the Xbox 360, due to the fact that it is free. But is $40.00 a year really too expensive for people?
Sony's servers aren't maintained by a customer base who pays for them. They're maintained by money that Sony keeps pouring into them. It's another way that they're losing money. In the future, you can be that Sony will make it's online service subscription based, in order to keep costs down, and maybe, one day, turn a profit.
So what do you get for $40.00 a year through Xbox Live? You get exclusive content, a chance to "Game with Fame",exclusive demos, insider news and tips, Games on Demand, and of course it's selection of Video Content. From television shows to new releases, there's something for everybody. You can purchase shows and rent movies through the marketplace, or stream them live from Netflix. Not only that, but the $40.00 a year helps fund updates, like bringing Facebook, Twitter, and Last.fm to Xbox Live. Granted, if you're an Xbox Live Family, it could be kind of expensive. A family plan subscription would be really nice of Microsoft to provide, but is it necessary? <!-- m --><a class="postlink" href="http://www.blippitt.com/xbox-360-sales-hit-30-million-live-subscribers-hit-20-million">http://www.blippitt.com/xbox-360-sales- ... 20-million</a><!-- m -->.
Informacion completa de la web:
<!-- m --><a class="postlink" href="http://www.examiner.com/x-16887-Las-Cruces-Xbox-Live-Examiner~y2009m8d30-Xbox-360-better-than-PS3-Part-one-hardware">http://www.examiner.com/x-16887-Las-Cru ... e-hardware</a><!-- m -->.
Xbox 360 better than PS3?
Part one: hardware
Since the release of the current generation of consoles, the debate has raged, not persisted, but raged about which company has the better console. However, even this question has been answered, time and time again, Sony, it's developers, and it's fans still proclaim that it is the better console. This is false.
With this generation of games there are three basic issues at hand that decide which console is the best. Hardware, Software, and online capability. We'll cover all of these in this article.
Hardware is the weapon that Sony and company touts more often than anything else. They constantly state how the PS3 is the more powerful system, because of the Cell Processor, and Blu-Ray. However, the PS3 is not the more powerful system. There is just one, Cell Proecssor, and the Blu-Ray has painful load times, while it has more space on the disk, it still loads slower than regular DLDVD format discs. This is one of the reasons a game must install to the hard drive. Sony likes to state that most of it's games wouldn't run on the Xbox 360 due to limitations of the disc. This is incorrect.
[It's] great for watching movies, but not so great for games. Getting data off the Blu-ray drive takes about twice as long as it does to get the same data off the 360's DVD drive. That translates into longer load times, or god forbid if you're streaming from disk, tighter constraints on the amount of data you can stream
For instance, in Resistance: Fall of Man, every art asset is stored on disk once for every level that uses it. So rather than storing one copy of a texture, you're storing it 12 times. If you took that entire game and removed all the duplicate data, it would likely fit on a DVD without any problem
- Jason Booth, Turbine and Harmonix Developer who produced titles such as Rock Band, and Guitar Hero.
There you have it from a developer who's made some of the most popular games today, Rock Band and Guitar Hero. So what is Blu-Ray really good for then? Watching movies? This isn't a score for Sony, because the 360 already lets you watch high definition movies in 1080p if you'd like. You can rent them from the market place, stream them from Netflix, or straight from your computer or mac. Blu-Ray may be able to hold a huge amount of data now, but is Blu-Ray really the future? No. Blu-Ray has arrived at the end of the disc era. Flash cards may very well be the next format, but digital downloads are storming consoles, especially with the 360's new ability to download full games, right onto the hard drive through Games on Demand.
Next up is graphics processing capabilities. Sony touts that it's Cell processor is more capable of providing better graphics than the Xbox's powerhouse tri-core processor. Jason booth says:
The fill rate on the PS3 is significantly slower than on the 360, meaning that games either have to run at lower resolution or use simpler shader effects to achieve the same performance, Additionally, the shader processing on the PS3 is significantly slower than on the 360, which means that a normal map takes more fill rate to draw on the PS3 than it does on the 360. And I'm not talking about small differences here, we're talking roughly half the pixel pushing power
Half of the pixel pushing power he says. Amazing. Here's a graph from an IGN and Gamespy Comparative analysis that shows the processing power of both the Xbox 360, and the PS3:
![[Image: microsofts-xbox-360-vs-sonys-playstation...728972.jpg]](http://image3.examiner.com/images/blog/wysiwyg/image/microsofts-xbox-360-vs-sonys-playstation-3-20050520041728972.jpg)
[img]For all of you interesting in reading the full article, complete with all it's technical terms read here.
Here's a graph that shows the shader operations per second, also courtesy of IGN:[/img]
![[Image: microsofts-xbox-360-vs-sonys-playstation...731425.jpg]](http://image3.examiner.com/images/blog/wysiwyg/image/microsofts-xbox-360-vs-sonys-playstation-3-20050520041731425.jpg)
The last graph we'll look at, is for system bandwidth, which is necessary for running more complex graphics.
![[Image: microsofts-xbox-360-vs-sonys-playstation...725628.jpg]](http://image3.examiner.com/images/blog/wysiwyg/image/microsofts-xbox-360-vs-sonys-playstation-3-20050520041725628.jpg)
The Cell processor is supposed to make up for this issue, however, given the history of games that have appeared on both systems, such as every game that has been made for 360 and ported to PS3, we've seen that games look significantly better on 360. Take a look at this article from The Sixth Axis, a predominately PS3 website, which showed that the PS3 couldn't support high resolution for the game Ghostbusters, without a patch, and after the patch, still called sub-hd by Gamezine.
Id Software (creators of Doom, Quake, and anticipated game Rage) director John Carmack said this:
What you can say really quite clearly and not get into too much argument about it is that the 360 is much easier to develop for, it's easier to get the performance out of it that it can deliver, and the rasterizer, the GPU side is generally faster than what the PS3 has.
And from a developer's standpoint, Gabe Newell from Valve, developer of Left 4 Dead, and Half Life 2, says,
I think [PS3 is] a waste of everybody’s time. Investing in the Cell, investing in the SPE gives you no long-term benefits. There’s nothing there that you’re going to apply to anything else. You’re not going to gain anything except a hatred of the architecture they’ve created. I don’t think they’re going to make money off their box.
So here we have multiple game developers stating what the hardware specifications reinforce. The Xbox 360 is the better system where hardware is concerned.
Part two: Software
Part two: Software
Games are always decision makers for people. Whether it's just some people, or all, they will always be a huge factor when deciding which console to buy.
Microsoft has made it it's a huge object in acquiring thirdy party software as exclusive titles to it's library. See the full list here. Please note that this list does not include games that have yet to be released.
Sony, on the other hand, has let exclusive deals go, and has even said that third party content isn't as important as first party content. The biggest thing however, is the list of former Sony exclusives who are bringing their wares to Microsoft. Here's a list of the biggest ones, some of which are new IPs that were intended to be PS3 exclusives:
* Final Fantasy XIII
* Fatal Inertia
* The Last Remnant
* Bladestorm
* Final Fantasy XIV
* Resident Evil
* Star Ocean
* Tekken
* Metal Gear Solid
* War Devil
* Merecnaries 2
* L.A. Noire
* Grand Theft Auto IV
* Assassins's Creed
* Left 4 Dead
* Splinter Cell: Conviction
Now, some of them have come across partially, while others like The Last Remnant, Star Ocean and Left 4 Dead, have come across completely as Xbox exclusives. The Xbox 360 has lost exclusivity on these games:
* Ninja Gaiden
* Lost Planet
* Bioshock
This list also doesn't include much of the Downloadable Content that Microsoft also has exclusive rights to, such as Grand Theft Auto: IV, and timed exclusive content on games like Fallout 3, and Call of Duty. Sony's exclusive games are primarily single player, whereas Xbox's are multiplayer. Single player games are becoming a thing of the past, as you can see with the Wii. Multiplayer, and cooperative play is where it's all at. The 360 has the PS3 beat here. And some people will say "oh it's because the 360 has been out longer. It's only been out for a year longer, and it has 21 more exclusives than the PS3. And they didn't all come out during that first year. Next: Online services.
Part three: Software
Part three: Software
Online is always the last weapon that Sony and it's fans use to determine which console is better. They maintain that the PS3 has better online support than the Xbox 360, due to the fact that it is free. But is $40.00 a year really too expensive for people?
Sony's servers aren't maintained by a customer base who pays for them. They're maintained by money that Sony keeps pouring into them. It's another way that they're losing money. In the future, you can be that Sony will make it's online service subscription based, in order to keep costs down, and maybe, one day, turn a profit.
So what do you get for $40.00 a year through Xbox Live? You get exclusive content, a chance to "Game with Fame",exclusive demos, insider news and tips, Games on Demand, and of course it's selection of Video Content. From television shows to new releases, there's something for everybody. You can purchase shows and rent movies through the marketplace, or stream them live from Netflix. Not only that, but the $40.00 a year helps fund updates, like bringing Facebook, Twitter, and Last.fm to Xbox Live. Granted, if you're an Xbox Live Family, it could be kind of expensive. A family plan subscription would be really nice of Microsoft to provide, but is it necessary? <!-- m --><a class="postlink" href="http://www.blippitt.com/xbox-360-sales-hit-30-million-live-subscribers-hit-20-million">http://www.blippitt.com/xbox-360-sales- ... 20-million</a><!-- m -->.
